New Delhi: Indian wrestler Vinesh Phogat’s hopes for a shared silver medal were dashed when her appeal against disqualification ahead of the Olympic final was rejected by the ad hoc division of the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS). The decision came after she weighed 100 grams above the prescribed limit for the women’s 50 kg freestyle wrestling category.
The Weighty Disqualification:
Vinesh Phogat, a 29-year-old wrestling sensation, had her dreams of becoming India’s first woman to compete in an Olympic final shattered. Instead of vying for gold, she faced disqualification due to the minor weight discrepancy. Her appeal sought credit for the three wins she earned after successfully weighing in on August 6.
IOA’s Strong Reaction:
The Indian Olympic Association (IOA) expressed shock and disappointment at the court’s ruling. IOA President PT Usha criticized the “inhuman rules” that failed to consider the psychological and physical stress faced by athletes. The decision not only impacts Vinesh’s career but also raises serious questions about the interpretation of ambiguous rules in international wrestling.
A Call for Review:
The IOA believes that declaring a player ineligible for such a minor weight difference on the second day of competition warrants a deeper review. Vinesh’s case highlights the need for more equitable and reasonable standards that prioritize athletes’ well-being. The decision serves as a “strong reminder” to reevaluate existing rules.
India’s Medal Tally:
With Vinesh’s disqualification, India’s medal count in the Paris Olympics stands at six comprising one silver and five bronze medals. Her retirement announcement via social media reflects the emotional toll of this setback.
The Unyielding Rules:
While sympathy favors Vinesh, International Olympic Committee chief Thomas Bach and UWW chief Nenad Lalovic maintain that altering the rules would have widespread consequences. The weight of these decisions extends beyond the wrestling mat, impacting athletes and the sports community at large.
*In summary, Vinesh Phogat’s disqualification reverberates through the Olympic arena, prompting calls for a fairer approach and a deeper understanding of the challenges faced by athletes.
